Net Neutrality: What the FCC’s decision means for the US.
Exactly what is Net Neutrality?
Net neutrality is the idea that an On line service ought not to separate between the different websites, applications, and services that are spread on its system. This could possibly be privately guaranteed, by means of an arrangement between a subscriber and their Internet based Service Provider, or it may be enforced by the government. Usually when “net neutrality” is spoken about, it refers to the idea of the government enforcing it. The agency which has taken on the objective of guaranteeing net neutrality is the Federal Communications Commission.
FCC’s Recent Net Neutrality Order
On December 21, 2010, the FCC voted in favor of pushing Net Service Providers to adopt net neutrality as a policy. The press release’s title was “FCC Acts to Preserve Web Freedom and Openness,” as only those who oppose freedom and openness may possibly be opposed to net neutrality. The FCC dedicated most of the second page of its press release to citing various statutory authorities in an attempt to explain why it ought to be able to implement this order-not exactly the appearance of confidence in the legality of what they are doing.
FCC Says no blocking
A person engaged in the provision of fixed broadband Web-based access service, insofar as such person is so engaged, shall not block lawful content, applications, services, or non-harmful devices, subject to reasonable system management.
A person employed in the provision associated with portable high speed On line access service, insofar as such person is so engaged, shall not block consumers from accessing lawful websites, subject to reasonable network system management; nor shall such person block applications that compete with the provider’s voice or video telephony services, subject to reasonable network management.
The effect of this law is to limit ISPs from determining when they may or may not restrict traffic. The term “reasonable network system management” has its own definition listed in the Report and Order, but it is so broad that it will inevitably permit the FCC to crack down on ISPs whenever it feels like doing so . If they engage in the most common Administrative Law practice, they are likely to litigate against smaller ISPs who have a lesser chance of defending themselves.
Net Neutrality isn’t new. . It previously attempted to regulate the network management practices of Comcast-specifically Comcast’s regulation of peer-to-peer file-sharing on its system. Although the FCC has attempted to justify its actions, it is still limited. ? 154(i)). Comcast subsequently set up a court challenge against the FCC, and in April 2010 the US Court of Appeals in the District of Columbia sided with Comcast and granted its order for review of the FCC’s decision.
It should be noted, however, that previous cases have stated that the FCC’s exercise of power is limited Commission authority.”
There are numerous economic and constitutional issues with the recent net neutrality legislation from the FCCThis has not stopped the FCC from taking action, however. Aside from the fact that an administrative agency is taking seemingly even greater liberties than those which were struck down in the Comcast case earlier this year , and extinguishing Congress’ wish to debate the law, the businesses which are affected are going to suffer. Simply by keeping businesses from determining which traffic may be limited, the FCC is going to give them two choices:
1) Deal with overburdened networks;
2) Increase the aggregate network bandwidth but distribute costs evenly so that those who may use the Word wide web for only basic browsing and e-mail have to pay for the iTunes downloads of someone else.
Frequently option, it will not look good for ISPs and also their own customers who use less bandwidth than their fellow subscribers . It’s going to be interesting to watch the coming court cases over the next year or so, which ISPs and possibly affected consumers will no doubt want to launch. The nation’s lawmakers may most likely join in the fray, too.
If you would like to learn more about how the new net neutrality law affects you, or would like assistance in considering possible legal options regarding the law, please contact a qualified On line law attorney.
The Kelly Law Firm handles internet law and net neutrality law issues.
Processing your request, Please wait....
